Some years ago, I was guest-preaching at a local church when a man came up to me after the service and said while he had enjoyed the service very much, he wondered why we couldn’t sing “the good old hymns” like In the Garden.

I paused and then began the following conversation: “Let’s think about that for a moment. The chorus goes And He walks with me, and He talks with me, and He tells me I am his own. And the joy we share as we tarry there, none other has ever known. To me, it sounds like this person is saying that she has a more intimate relationship with Christ than anyone else on earth. Do you think that is possible?”

“No, I don’t.”

“Well, it’s those words – the idea that this person is somehow more loved by Jesus than anyone else – those words are the reason I have never chosen this hymn for worship.”’

“Hmmm …. I guess I never really thought much about the words – I just liked the song. But I get it now.”

How many times in worship do we sing hymns or songs without really paying attention to what we are singing? But we should pay attention to texts we sing in worship because they both inform our faith and reflect it.

The author of the New Testament book called Colossians urges his readers to cast off their old ways and embrace their new life in Christ, laying out the signs of this new life: compassion, kindness, humility, meekness and patience. He then goes on to describe how the Colossians should treat each other before concluding, “Let the word of Christ dwell in you richly; teach and admonish one another in all wisdom; and with gratitude in your hearts sing psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs to God.”

As the Colossians grow in their faith, music will play an important role in keeping them focused on God. And it still plays that role today, but sometimes we need to ask if what we are singing truly reflects the God whom we are praising.

When I was a child, I loved the hymn “Onward, Christian Soldiers” (Onward, Christian soldiers, marching as to war…) But then I grew up and learned about the Crusades and the awful things that were done by soldiersin the name of Christ and suddenly I just couldn’t, in good conscience, sing that hymn any more.

And the same thing happened with another hymn I loved when I was young, The Old Rugged Cross” whose chorus goes: So I’ll cherish the old rugged cross till my trophies at last I lay down. I will cling to the old rugged cross and exchange it some day for a crown. I thought nothing of singing those words when I was young, but now I cringe at the thought of sentimentalizing what was a horrific instrument of torture and death.

And I think the hymn misses the point of what Jesus calls us to do, which is not to cling to the cross on which Jesus died but to go out into the world and show how Jesus lived. And we don’t do this because we want to guarantee our place in heaven but because we are committed not only to praying that God’s will done on earth as it is in heaven, but doing what we can to make that prayer a realitiy.

But it’s not only some of the beloved old hymns that are problematic in their theology – there are, unfortunately, more than a few contemporary Christian praise songs that embrace a theology that says Jesus had to die to pay the price of sin demanded by a just God. But what earthly judge would accept the sacrifice of an innocent person instead of a guilty one? And what kind of earthly parent would punish a child for the misdeeds of his siblings? The doctrine of substitutionary atonement has a lot of holes in it, but it shows up far too often in Christian hymns and praise songs.

The words we sing in worship matter more than we might realize. Years ago when I was serving a church in Wheaton, Illinois, the husband-wife team who served as the church organist and choir director had a sign in their office that said, “For heights and depths no words can reach, music is the soul’s own speech.”

I think there is a lot of truth to that statement; and when a well-written text is set to music, it can be incredibly powerful.

Think of the enslaved people in this country and how cathartic it must have been for them to sing: Go down Moses, way down in Egypt’s land. Tell ol’ Pharaoh to let my people go. When they sang this song, they expressed their deepest hope and they firm belief that God is on the side of the oppressed.

Or consider the hymn “God of Grace and God of Glory” – I suppose it’s no surprise that it has an enduring place in Presbyterian worship since the words Save us from weak resignation to the evils we deplore continue to resonate with our situation today and we still need to ask God to grant us wisdom, grant us courage as we navigate the fractured landscape of our nation.

Or take a good look at the words we will sing in a few moments – go ahead now and look at that text. (Pause) John Bell from the Iona Community in Scotland wrote this hymn in 1989 and set it to a familiar Scottish folk tune so that it could be used in services of prayer and healing at Iona Abbey.

It’s a powerful text at any time but think about how these words were experienced when they were sung in Dunblane Cathedral in Scotland in March of 1996 at the memorial service for 16 schoolchildren and their teacher who were killed in what has been described as an “American-style” school shooting. This text must have pierced right to the heart of those who were grieving even as it reminded them they were not alone in their grief.

Psalm 96 encourages us to sing a new song unto the Lord, and one of the reasons I love World Communion Sunday so much is that it gives us a chance to do just that – to sing songs that may be new to us, songs that come from Christian communities all around the world – including communities where poverty is a constant presence. And yet the songs we sang today from Africa and Latin America, from parts of the world were life can be at times very precarious, nonetheless radiate joy and an enduring trust in the love of God.

Music is the soul’s own speech and the words we sing in worship matter deeply as they both inform and express our faith. So may we always take the time to think about we are singing in worship so that the words of our mouths – both spoken and sung – will always be pleasing to God.